home / news & insights /
The Supreme Court ruled in two recent judgments that reassuring statements by defendants may cause that the injured party does not yet have the necessary knowledge and insight for the (short) limitation period of Art. 3:310 (1) of the Civil Code to start.[1] The judgment is important for legal practice, as reassuring statements are regularly issued by parties that have committed wrongful acts, and often, therefore, the limitation period will start to run later than was assumed.
Background
In one of the cases the situation was the following. The plaintiff and a bank had a credit relationship from 1992 to April 2016. The plaintiff took out an account overdraft and a roll-over-loanat a variable interest rate. To hedge the interest rate risk, the plaintiff also purchased two interest rate swaps and later renewed these products. Ultimately, these financial products were disadvantageous for the plaintiff: the plaintiff suffered financial losses.
The plaintiff filed a claim against the bank arguing that the bank did not properly advise it on the risks of the interest rate swap and its renewal. The district court and the court of appeal both dismiss the claim. The court ruled that there was no breach of duty of care by the bank. The court of appeal ruled that the plaintiff’s claims were barred by the expiry of the five-year limitation period of Art. 3:310(1) of the Dutch Civil Code. That judgment was appealed to the Supreme Court by the plaintiff.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court first outlined the established rules and case law on limitation periods under Dutch law:
The Supreme Court then evaluated the relevant circumstances in the judgment. It held that reassuring statements from the liable person may lead to the injured party not having the knowledge and insight to assess the legitimacy of the actions. At the same time, the absence of reassuring statements does not ensure awareness of the damage and the liable person.[5] With this guidance, the Supreme Court sent the case back to the court of appeal for further consideration.
Impact on legal practice
The judgment is of great importance for legal practice, for example in claims in relation to financial products and other products where the buyer does not have specialized knowledge. When the buyer – often a consumer – buys such products, the seller regularly gives explicit advice. That advice is often focused on selling the (financial) product and less on informing the consumer. In that situation, there may be too little warning and too much reassurance. Just as often, the existence of wrongful acts and damages are vehemently contested by defendants. With its ruling, the Supreme Court attaches possible consequences to such statements to injured parties: a postponement of the starting date of the limitation period.
[1] Supreme Court 12 January 2024, ECLI:NL:HR:2024:18 and Supreme Court 12 January 2024, ECLI:NL:HR:2024:19.
[2] Supreme Court 12 January 2024, ECLI:NL:HR:2024:18, para 3.5.
[3] Ibidem, para 3.6.
[4] Ibidem, para 3.7.
[5] Ibidem, para 3.9 and Supreme Court 12 January 2024, ECLI:NL:HR:2024:19.
25 April 2024 - Insights
Lindenbaum covered the significant recent developments in cartel litigation in the Netherlands in an article for Global Legal Insights.
Read more30 March 2024 - News
We are proud to share that Lindenbaum has been ranked in the Legal 500 as one of the leading firms in the Netherlands in the EMEA 2024 rankings. The firm has been ranked in the "Dispute resolution: class actions category", and is noted as a “firm to watch” in the "Dispute Resolution: Commercial Litigation" and "EU and Competition categories".
Read more20 February 2024 - News
The International Bar Association will be hosting their three-day Annual Litigation Forum in Amsterdam from 17 to 19 April 2024. This year the Forum will revolve around key litigation themes such as The Hague Convention, cross-border enforcement, the handling of expert witnesses, and trends in class actions. Lindenbaum will be sponsoring the conference diner, and our partners Guido Vergouwen and Damiën Berkhout will be delegates at the Forum.
Read more